Really, Really Ugly
The very worst of Olympia's rubbish, however, is SB 5776, a partisan
electoral "reform" measure that includes a particularly vile bid by state
Republislug leaders to ban Native American tribes from contributing to
electoral campaigns. Other provisions loosen donation reporting
requirements in the final days of a campaign (a change favoring very large
donors) and severely limit the ability of unions to contribute to
campaigns.
According to 5776's lead sponsor, Bob McCaslin of Spokane, the tribal
portion is a response to large Native American donations in the failed
effort to pass a pro-gaming initiative in last fall's election. McCaslin:
"You wonder why sovereign nations want to make campaign
contributions."
Answer: because Washington state--and idiots like McCaslin--have fought
tribal sovereignty every step of the way since 1889. The few sovereign
rights tribes forced courts to honor in recent years (notably treaty
fishing rights and gaming) were won over the fierce and ongoing
opposition of official Washington.
The problem is simple. Native Americans are U.S. citizens; a law that
states that a collection of U.S. citizens can't lobby or exercise free
speech (courts consider campaign donations to be both) is plainly
unconstitutional. Since the defining characteristic of tribes is race, it
also meets any legal test for racial discrimination. It's also the
ultimate in hypocrisy. If reservations were respected as sovereign
nations they wouldn't need to have a vote of approval from the state of
Washington. Native Americans should be able to do whatever the hell
they want on their own land.
Instead, the constant official harassment for any meager steps to
alleviate the crushing poverty of most reservations is a testimony to the
two-faced utility of state and federal government attitudes toward native
rights. When the feds want to dump toxic or nuclear waste, corporations
want waived environmental, worker safety, or minimum wage regulations, and
states want to withhold social services, sovereignty is great. When tribes
assert fishing rights, economic development, control over forests or miner
als on their land, or (gasp) start to get some money in their pockets, all
hell breaks loose.
The root problem for McCaslin et al isn't gaming or campaign finance: it's
people of color with money. SB 5776 is one of the most transparently
racist bills to come along in years. Even with a certain Locke veto, this
bill shouldn't ever be allowed to get to his desk. SB 5776 must be
stopped.
|