A League of Their Own
Two new stadiums, plus $150 million in debt on the to-be-demolished
Kingdome, plus the costs of demolition, add up to
a corporate welfare scam easily topping $1 billion--and
that's before further cost overruns, infrastructure costs
and interest on the next 20 years' worth of bonds. But the
actual problem is much bigger. Welfare for professional
sports has quietly become a major national scandal--one
blackmailed city or state at a time.
Stadiums aren't an issue of one or another city that faces
loss of a team if it doesn't pony up. The real issue is a
highly visible and profitable entertainment industry, owned
by some of the nation's wealthiest people, that bases its
economic structure on profiting from public expenditures. We
pay, they take it to the bank.
How bad is it? Here's an incomplete list of 29 cities either
building or facing demands to build playpens for 62 teams in
one or more of the four major pro men's team sports:
Seattle: Sure, there's the Mariners, the Seahawks,
and the Kingdome debt. But don't forget the year-old Key
Arena. Seattle Coliseum was rebuilt for the Sonics mostly
with private money, but the city donated admissions taxes
and other significant low-Key welfare concessions worth
millions.
Portland: A task force is drumming up money and
support to build a new baseball and/or football stadium to
attract a pro franchise, with ownership probably to be
headed by Nike CEO and renowned good guy Phil Knight.
San Francisco: After a ten-year succession of failed
ballot box attempts to get the public to build a new
baseball stadium for the Giants, one is being built with
mostly private financing. The 49ers are now proposing a
combination football stadium/mall (their owner is a major
shopping mall developer) with private and public funding.
Oakland: The Golden State Warriors are rebuilding
their basketball arena this year. Oakland A's and Raiders
(football and baseball) both want out of Alameda County
Coliseum; the Raiders were promised a new stadium as part of
their return to Oakland from Los Angeles last year, and the
city of Oakland is now losing oodles of money on the deal.
Los Angeles: After both NFL teams bolted town last
year, the scramble is on to build a new state-of-the-art,
perhaps $1 billion football stadium to attract a new NFL
team. Both baseball teams, the Dodgers and Anaheim Angels,
want new stadiums as well; the Dodgers are for sale.
San Diego: Expansion of Jack Murphy Stadium (baseball
and football) has been derailed for the moment by a
threatened citizen initative, which--if not resolved in the
next few weeks--could "force" the NFL to relocate next
year's Super Bowl.
Phoenix: Is building a new, retractable-roof baseball
stadium for an expansion team due to start play next year.
The football team, the Arizona Cardinals, wants a new
stadium, too. Basketball and hockey got a new arena a couple
years ago.
San Antonio: The San Antonio Spurs are threatening to
move if a new arena isn't built to replace the Alamodome,
which opened about ten years ago.
Houston: The football team (Oilers) is apparently
moving after not getting their dream stadium, but voters
last fall approved a new stadium to keep the Astros baseball
club. The city is also trying to attract an NHL hockey
franchise.
Minneapolis: A convoluted deal to sell the state of
Minnesota 49% of the Minnesota Twins as part of a new
stadium package appears to be unravelling. The football
Vikings also want a new stadium; and neighboring St. Paul is
promising a new hockey arena to attract an NHL team.
Milwaukee: While the publicly owned Green Bay Packers
enjoy the limelight, the Milwaukee Brewers (once the Seattle
Pilots, and now owned by baseball commissioner, Bud Selig)
have failed in several legislative and ballot attempts so
far to get a new park. The city also wants a new hockey
team.
Chicago: The Bears are shopping throughout Chicago
and Northwest Indiana for a new State-of-the-Avarice
football site.
Memphis: Efforts to build a new football stadium to
attract an NFL team appear to have died down.
Nashville: A new football stadium is being built to
bring the Houston Oilers to town in two years. A new
basketball/hockey arena built three years ago has yet to
have similar success luring a team.
Atlanta: On the heels of massive public underwriting
of 1996 Summer Olympics facilities, a new baseball stadium
will open this spring. The football stadium opened a couple
years ago.
Tampa Bay: A new baseball stadium awaits an expansion
baseball franchise in St. Petersburg. The Tampa Bay
Buccaneers (football), after threatening to move for years,
finally got approval for a new stadium this past fall.
Miami: The Florida Panthers hockey team wants a new
arena. Baseball's Florida Marlins want a new stadium.
Charlotte: The Beehive, considered state-of-the-art
when it was built for basketball's expansion Charlotte
Hornets less than ten years ago, now "needs" replacement.
Erickson Stadium opened for football's Carolina Panthers
this past fall.
Cincinnati: Baseball has a team the city loves and a
vile owner. Football has a beloved owner and an horrid team.
Both want separate new stadiums.
Columbus: Trying to lure an NHL hockey expansion team
with promises of a new arena.
Cleveland: In the highest-profile franchise shift in
years, Cleveland lost its football team when it wouldn't
match the extravagant offer of the state of Maryland. It's
building a new stadium anyway, for a promised expansion
team; both the baseball and basketball teams got new city-funded
homes in the last five years.
Detroit: Only about 15 years old, the Silverdome
(football and basketball) is being torn down as both teams
got new homes. Baseball's venerable Tiger Stadium is also
being replaced in the next two years.
Toronto: Both the basketball and hockey teams want
new arenas; it appears they will be separate new facilities.
Washington DC: Northern Virginia investors want a new
suburban stadium to lure baseball. On the Maryland side,
after a huge bill to build new baseball and football
stadiums in Baltimore in the last five years, state
residents are facing yet another bill to pay for the new
suburban stadium opening for football's Washington Redskins.
New York City: Baseball's Yankees have been playing a
bidding war between NYC and New Jersey to see who will
finance a $1 billion plus new stadium.
Long Island: The Islanders want a new hockey arena.
Boston: Fenway Park is the third of the remaining
very old ballparks to be headed for rubble. Meanwhile, the
New England Patriots are shopping all over Massachusetts and
Rhode Island for a willing football site. A hockey and
basketball facility, the Fleet Center, opened last year.
Add in payments for existing facilities and all the other
public subsidies these games take in each city, plus
national breaks like baseball's notorious exemption from
federal anti-trust laws. The total bill, nationally, for
direct public bankrolling of this immensely profitable
private industry comes to many billions each year.
Does Paul Allen really need more of our money?
|