Where Your Income Tax Dollars Really Go
April 15 is "Tax Day." Of the 68,351 government entities in the
U.S. with the power to tax, the federal government is the largest,
the income tax is the most visible, and April 15 is when we're
most aware of how much we're paying. But what doesn't get quite as
much attention is where the money goes, and the net effect. Put
simply, with corporate and high-income tax rates slashed, and
social services cut way back, most of the income tax money is
coming from lower and middle classes, and going to corporations
and the very wealthy.
One of the major reasons this trend doesn't get much attention in,
say, corporate media (besides the obvious reason) is that the feds
themselves disguise the nature of spending. A typical government
press release on how federal money is proposed to be spent in FY
1998 looks like this:
50% Direct benefit payments for individuals
15% Grants to states and localities
15% Net interest
15% Military
5% Other federal operations
Charts like this fuel the myth that welfare queens and
out-of-control social programs are the cause of rampant government
overspending. But there are a few things wrong here.
First, the above percentages include trust funds (like Social
Security) as well as general fund dollars (which is where income
taxes are deposited). Since Congress has no say over trust funds
in the federal budget--they just sit there--it's irrelevant to
policy decisions. The government started listing trust funds in
budget figures during the Vietnam War, to disguise the size of
military spending. Bureaucrats aren't as dumb as you think.
About military costs: that 15% is strictly Department of Defense.
It doesn't include the U.S. nuclear weapons program (under Dept.
of Energy), NASA funding (primarily military), the CIA or any of
the secret National Security Act agencies, or discretionary money
available to the President for foreign adventures. It also, of
course, doesn't include the costs of past of the interest on the
national debt. Add it all up and direct militarism accounts for
49% of discretionary federal spending in FY 1998.
The "benefit payments to individuals" is also misleading. The
largest chunk of it is Medicare--most of which doesn't end up with
individuals at all, but in the inflated wallets of health care
providers, insurance, and pharmaceutical companies. Every other
major spending sector--Education, Health and Human Services, HUD
housing subsidies, food stamps, the Labor Department--has been
continuously cut back and/or shipped out to the (more
conservative) states under Bill Clinton.
|