| |
Workers on the Scrap Heap
by Maria Tomchick
The State Department of Labor and Industries reported in
early January (as covered in the P-I, Jan. 9) that it paid
$2.7 billion in worker's comp benefits to people with back
and arm injuries suffered on the job from 1989 through 1996.
Two-thirds of the back injury claims were due to repetitive
motion stress, and only one-third to heavy-lifting. All
repetitive-motion injuries (arm, back, wrist, etc.) accounted
for over one-third of all damages paid out over that same
time period.
This report is the first detailed worker's comp study of
repetitive-motion injuries in the country. Yet, it's far from
comprehensive; to gauge the true impact, we would also have
to count employees of companies that are self-insured.
Several large Washington manufacturers take out private
worker's comp insurance in order to shop around for better
(cheaper) rates and to limit the payouts made to injured
employees. Companies that self-insure also have more control
over which doctors their employees can see (doctors that are
unwilling to diagnose repetitive-motion injuries, for
example). The Boeing Co., which is rumored to have high
levels of job-related injuries and has been sued by
chemically-injured employees, is self-insured.
In addition, many companies encourage (or intimidate) workers
into using the company's or the worker's own health insurance
plans to pay for treatment of on-the-job injuries, instead of
filing a claim with L&I. L&I sponsors regular classes and
sends publications to employers on worker's comp law and how
to "minimize" worker's comp claims. It also gives tax breaks
to employers who hold down their total worker's comp claims.
Yet L&I provides very little information or outreach to
educate workers about safety on the job, beyond the simple
requirement that all employers must put up a poster on the
premises listing a worker's right to file a claim with L&I in
case of injury on the job. Enforcement of this simple rule is
lax, unless an employee complains to L&I.
An increase in the use of temp or contract workers has
increased the overall rate of repetitive motion injuries.
According to the study, employers seem to be hiring temps to
do tedious work, then throwing them away when they "wear
out," shifting the injury costs onto temp agencies or the
individual workers themselves.
The industries showing the highest level of back and arm
injuries include: nursing homes, construction trades,
logging, sawmills, wholesale meat packing, and fruit and
vegetable packing plants. White collar office workers also
show high rates of arm injuries, as do apple pickers and
supermarket checkers. The main risk factors include: heavy or
repetitive lifting or pushing, handling objects far from the
body, handling objects above the shoulder or below knuckle
height or in a twisted position, moving or handling objects
over other obstructions, extreme or prolonged awkward
postures, and fast-paced work with little control over the
way the job is done.
Once a person suffers from a repetitive motion injury, the
healing process is slow and often incomplete. Many folks wait
until the pain is unbearable and irreparable damage is done
until they say anything to their supervisor or go see a
doctor. All workers need to know that they have the right to
refuse to do any activity that can injure them for life or
saddle them with a chronic pain condition, regardless of how
it impacts the company's bottom line. And in these days of
cynical griping about unions, we tend to forget that forming
a union in a workplace can improve job safety faster than any
individual complaints to the boss or phone calls to L&I.
|