Don't Get Sick
by Geov Parrish
The advice--demand, actually--from politicians and corporations who have
made a disaster of U.S. health care could hardly be clearer. People who
do get sick risk dying. Unless your illness is profitable to
somebody, don't expect help.
There are few people in the U.S. who don't worry about what will happen if
they fall ill--and not many who can afford the level of preventive care
standard in other Western countries. But a little-noticed report, released
(and given a one-day Congressional hearing) by the General Accounting
Office, gave a scary glimpse into how bad it has gotten, when even the
reformist triumphs ring hollow.
The report concerned 1996's "Health Insurance Portability and
Accountability Act." It is the Clinton Administration's one actual
constructive response to six years of escalating health industry crisis.
Well, never mind. The GAO sez the law ain't working; numerous loopholes
allow insurance companies to jack up rates prohibitively or limit policies
so as to foil lawmakers' intent.
The same market logic doomed Washington state's health care reform, even
before its Republican caucus did. Not that the GOP hasn't helped; in Oly
this year, they refused to allocate money to add 8,000 of the 600,000 on
the waiting list for the state's Basic Health Plan. Or money for matching
federal funds to cover indigent children's care.
The reason the U.S. has the developed world's most expensive health care,
and the poorest public health statistics, is that we insist on putting
private profit in the equation. Governments help by underwriting drug
research, limiting competition, and winking at $100 billion a year in
insurance-industry health care fraud (by GAO estimate). The byzantine
payment rules are also rigged for private profit. As a tiny example of
federal largesse, in 1995 Clinton's Dept. of Health and Human Services
lifted the requirement of "reasonable pricing" on drugs developed in
cooperation between the feds and private industry. Industries can now
charge whatever for drugs developed with tax money--including charging
Medicaid, Medicare, and other federal agencies that are, again, tax-funded.
We pay to give them the drug, then we pay again to get it back. A recent
study lists the American Medical Association--not the NRA or Christian
Coalition (or Boeing)--as the biggest-spending lobbyist in D.C.
Pharmaceuticals like Eli Lilly and Bristol-Myers are notoriously generous
campaign donors.
A simple solution is out there for many such ills: abolish the private
insurance industry except for elective procedures. It's worked in Canada,
Europe, and Japan. Alas, its legislative champion, Seattle's Jim McDermott,
has apparently decided he'd rather help Boeing make more of its planes in
China. Absent organized public outcry, are we surprised?
|