| |
Y1.999K: The Most Overrated and Underrated Stories of the Year
In 1998, the consolidation of corporate media, in both ownership and news
content, continued to rage unabated. In Seattle and nationally, in TV, radio,
newspaper, magazine, and, yes, Internet, editors consensed without even
knowing it on the stories we, the news-consuming public, most needed to know.
The results were not good.
Most Overrated Stories
With Clinton's sex scandal, the award for most overrated story can
safely be retired for posterity. If the worst imaginable outcome happens (it
won't), and Al Gore becomes president for a year or so, it will bring
virtually no change to any policies of consequence. If, as is far more
likely, Clinton is merely disgraced, we will have spend millions of dollars
and air hours confirming what anyone with an IQ over 14 already knows: anyone
with the ambition to hold high elected office in the U.S. is almost certainly
a jerk. Including both Bill and his persecuters. Instead, put them all on
trial for their very real crimes against the electorate.
In Seattle, the desire for a good sex story resulted in the overcoverage of
Mary Kay LeTourneau and her nasty habit of having kids by a former
student, still well under age. Oddly enough, media interest in this story
started to wane when said boy started asserting himself as a, well,
adolescent boy, making it a bit harder to portray LeTourneau as evil
incarnate.
Special kudos here go to the Seattle Post-Intelligencer--goodness knows,
their editors want awards for it--and its grotesque overhype of the
Wenatchee sex ring story. Granted, the overturning of several
convictions in the case merits attention--but the P-I gave the story its own
cute graphic, literally dozens of editorials, op-eds, and editorial cartoons
to back up its months of righteous indignation, and very little coverage of
the "other" side: the side that says there were very real reasons for
believing abuse occurred.
While the P-I went for sex, the Seattle Times went for something even better:
public-private partnerships. Here, the usual blitz of editorials, op-
eds, and biased coverage couldn't make up for the fact that the Schell
administration had virtually no support outside the usual downtown suspects
(championed by the Times) for the usual array of taxpayer-funded corporate
welfare schemes. The death of the 2012 Olympics may have been the most
satisfying comeuppance for the Times in years--or at least since the Seattle
Commons.
The Times also led the way--barely--in local and national media's obsession
with our need to shop. It's essential for business success, the health
of the economy, and our national vitality, you know. For details, we go live
to the mall!
No survey of local media would be complete without mentioning the biased
overcoverage of Boeing (especially poor stock performance) and Microsoft
(especially anti-trust proceedings). Of course, poor stock performance
wasn't just a local problem. Every day (it seemed) media idiots reported
breathlessly on the latest yo-yoing of the Dow Jones, as though it
mattered to the audience. And the hourly utterances of Alan Greenspan-
-which propelled most of that yo-yoing--can go, too.
Lastly, there's the perennials: overhyped weather events, sports scores,
celebrities, fashion, horoscopes, pet features, or tragedy-stricken children
(or tragedy-stricken school superintendents). Obvious, so it has to be
said: these are products of a profit-driven entertainment industry. There is
nothing wrong with being entertained. But it's not news.
One More Thing: We're a year away, and I'm already so fucking sick of
the fraud that is Y2K hysteria and general millenial kitsch that I could
scream, barf, or maybe even turn the TV off.
The Most Underrated Stories, At Home And Abroad
Planet Continues to Die: Here's what we wrote in this category the
last two years: "For a time in past years, things like ozone holes, global
warning, mass species extinctions, and toxic waste attracted headlines and
scientific concern. The concern is increasing, and the headlines have
disappeared. Not only has the Antarctic ozone hole widened, but a matching
Arctic hole extends at times as far south as Seattle. (Vancouver, B.C. media
reports local ozone counts; Canada, like the rest of the world, is a bit more
worried than we are.) The rainforests, of course, continue to fall as fast as
they can be processed into disposable chopsticks. Global warming is now an
accepted fact. Cancers and other illnesses based on chemical sensitivities
are fast becoming a global epidemic. The U.S. continues to work hard to stall
international agreements that might cut into transnational profits in an
attempt to save life on Earth."
Add declining sperm counts, genetic engineering, contaminated food
supplies, polluted oceans, and the Al Gore For President Campaign, and
it'sclear that our biosphere is in even greater danger 12 months later. The
crisis, when mentioned at all, is portrayed as a crisis in potential
corporate earnings. May the cockroaches have pity on our souls.
Boeing Goes To War: Boeing, with its acquisition of Rockwell and
McDonnell Douglas, became one of the world's leading arms dealers. You'd
never know it from the extensive and fawning coverage of local media--which,
between product release puff pieces, asks hard questions about production
techniques but never spends any time looking at where the finished products
are going, or which dictators are using them to murder which large masses of
civilians. That would be bad for business.
Anything to do with Local Politics. The Stranger and the Seattle
Weekly, the city's two alternative weeklies, are the city's only reliable
regular sources of local political news. The dailies, despite tremendous
resources, report on it glancingly and then often with the bias that comes
with golf dates with the heavy hitters. Television coverage of local politics
is an oxymoron. Overall, citizen knowledge of what's being done in our name
with our money is depressingly minimal; you have to be determined to find
out.
Specifically, the sea shift in Seattle's city council was a story that
didn't get much play. That deliberative body, thanks to three new progressive
voices and especially the leadership of Nick Licata, was more vibrant and
more of a force in city politics in 1998 than our supposedly visionary but in
fact curiously hands-off mayor, Paul Schell. His disappearance was another
barely-noticed local story, as was that of Republican-in-donkey-drag Governor
Gary Locke.--Geov Parrish
Foreign Stories of 1998
In recent years U.S. media, especially TV network news, has devoted less and
less space to foreign news. In 1998 the U.S. press did a particularly sad job
of covering international news. Here's a quick summary of the foreign stories
that were covered ad nauseam versus the really important stories that were
ignored. First, the drek:
Balkan bloodbath and carnage in the Congo. Body counts, burned
villages, troop movements--when it was covered, it was all served up in gory
detail, without a shred of background information, history, or on-the-spot
investigative reporting to make it meaningful.
The Middle East peace process that never was. This was a fiasco from
the start. No sooner had the U.S. press shouted that the Wye Accords were
Clinton's big foreign policy coup, than the Israeli government gave the
go-ahead to bulldoze more Palestinian homes to make way for even more
Israeli settlements. Almost nothing has changed in the West Bank and Gaza
Strip, yet the U.S. media continues to keep the "peace process" corpse
alive, day after day.
International terrorism. Terrorism kills one--sometimes two--dozen
U.S. citizens per year. Even when extremists hit a big target (like this
year's attack on the U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania) the number of
total Americans killed in all terrorist attacks is still less than the
number of people killed in a single large airplane crash, or are killed each
year by bad driving in Third World cities.
Boris Yeltsin's health. As if we care. Russians all know he's not
running the country anymore, but somehow the U.S. press hasn't figured it
out yet. Russia's a mess that has a lot bigger problems than Yeltsin's bad
heart and alcoholism. So why do our newspapers devote several column inches
to his every sneeze?
Other trivial items: North Korean nukes, Iranian nukes, suitcase bombs,
and chemical or biological weapons in Iraq. These stupid stories have
been repeated so often that most people believe they're true, in spite of
the lack of hard evidence to support any of them.
Here's my short list of 1998's most important international stories
not widely covered in the U.S. press:
Major breakthroughs in the enforcement of international human rights
laws, including: the establishment of an international court to try war
criminals, the release of South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation
Commission report, the trial and conviction of several war criminals in
Rwanda and Bosnia, and the arrest of Augusto Pinochet.
Meanwhile, human rights continued to be violated all around the
globe on the 50th anniversary of the U.N. Declaration of Human Rights.
Most of the offenders continue to do it to retain political power, to gain
control of natural resources, or to keep the poor marginalized. Some of the
worst offenders: Serbia, Indonesia, Colombia, Algeria, Burma, China, troops
fighting on both sides in the Congo war, the Taliban in Afghanistan, and
the U.S. government--just to name a few.
A combination of mal-development and global warming turned Central
America into a wasteland. The main culprit: corporate, plantation
agriculture, which had pushed most of Central America's rural poor up into
the hills to farm on steep slopes. Denuded of brush and natural vegetation,
those slopes quickly turned into massive mudslides during Hurricane Mitch's
heavy rains. The lack of government money for social spending, disaster
relief, and disaster planning (casualties of IMF "reforms") in these
countries were no help, either.
Asian economic crisis spreads to Russia and Latin America. Russia
defaulted on its domestic debt this year, and won't be able to pay its
foreign debt due at the end of this month. A second default is likely.
Brazil, Ecuador, Venezuela, and Argentina have all needed help from banks
and the IMF to stay afloat. And now Mexico is teetering on the edge ...
Collapse of Mexican banks. Sinking under massive debt left over from
the 1994 crisis, a number of Mexican banks have gone under. The Mexican
government wants to bail them out to the tune of $60 billion, but it
doesn't have the money--primarily because of a huge drop in oil prices. Oil
revenue makes up about 30-40% of the Mexican government's income.
The collapse of commodity prices has turned a world-wide recession into
a Depression, and it's hitting the poorest nations the hardest. As
populous nations (Russia, Indonesia, India, Brazil, etc.) succumbed to
currency crises in the past year, they couldn't afford to buy imported
foods, fuel, or other commodities. As demand dried up, commodity prices
plummeted. Now most Third World countries, whose economies rely heavily on
export commodities, are suffering terribly.
And that's my list--not edited to please investors, boost the Dow, attract
advertisers, or sell tennis shoes. Here's to a happy--and hopefully
better--New Year!
--Maria Tomchick
|