One Side of the Story
by Peter Phillips
A major news story about Serbia, not covered in the American press, was
published in Covert Action Quarterly (CAQ) last fall.
The story detailed how a famous photo from 1992 in Omarska, Bosnia which
depicted an alleged Serbian death camp, was in fact a phony. The original
photo, taken by Independent Television (ITN) from Great Britain, showed an
emaciated Muslim man with his shirt off behind barbed wire with his
imprisoned comrades behind him. This photo ran worldwide and was just used
again on June 14th by Time magazine.
It was the first significant emotional presentation of the Serbian military
as Nazi-like thugs. Presidential candidate Bill Clinton, making reference
to the photo, promised military action against the Serbs if elected.
According to CAQ this photo was a gross misrepresentation of the situation.
The men in the picture were not behind barbed wire, but were standing
outside of a small fenced enclosure next to a farm house in an open field
that had been serving as a refugee transit site. The photographers shot the
photo from within the fenced enclosure looking out on a open field. The
Hague Tribunal confirmed in 1994 that there was no barbed wire surrounding
the camp at Omarska in 1992.
So how has a phony photo of an alleged Serbian death camp continued to be
used to portray the Serbian government as an holocaust perpetrator in
Kosovo? One part of the answer is that the American public relations firm
Ruder Finn was originally hired by Croatian secessionists, Bosnian Muslims,
and the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) to foster negative images of the Serbs
as Nazi demons.
Ruder Finn has targeted American women and Jews by promoting often
unconfirmed news stories of Serbian rape/death camps and various human
atrocities. News stories showing attacks and ethnic cleansing of Serbs have
often been repressed or played down. The result is that the American public
has been lead to believe that the Serbs are the vicious aggressors in the
Balkans and the other parties are merely innocent victims. Nothing could be
further from the truth.
The KLA itself was listed by the U.S. State department as a terrorist
organization until just last year. They have conducted bombings,
assassinations, ambushes, (financed by heroin sales) on both Albanians
moderates and Serbs in Kosovo for several years, increasing their attacks
by 1,000% in 1998.
Serbian police responses were often brutal, especially in the villages from
which the KLA was known to operate. Yet, last year only 2,000 deaths
occurred on both sides in all of Kosovo. In this case, 2,000 deaths is not
an ethnic cleansing campaign by Serbs to kill Albanians, but rather part of
a measured response to ongoing terrorist activities by a legitimate
government.
The American media has been so accepting of demonize-the-Serb stories that
there was no questioning of the news story last January of the alleged
Serbian massacre at Racak where some 40 Kosovo Albanians were said to have
been gunned down by Serb police. Investigated by the "neutral" former
Oliver North aide, William Walker, the bodies were a perfect photo
opportunity to justify increased NATO demands for direct intervention and
the bombings. Yet, there was a complete failure of the American press to
cover the European Union's forensic team's report on March 17th stating
that they were unable to confirm that a massacre had occurred, and that it
was possible that the bodies had been moved to that location after death.
The American press has been filled with daily reports of mass graves and
torture sites in Kosovo. Yet, a recent story of a KLA torture chamber found
by German NATO troops received scant attention in the press. Perhaps if the
Serbs buried the 2,000 plus civilian victims of NATO's bombing campaign in
a single mass grave, the U.S. press might pay more attention to both sides
of the story instead of serving as a NATO disinformation distribution
service.
Peter Phillips, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Sociology at Somona State
University and Director of Project Censored.
Editor's note: more information on William Walker and the Racak incident
can be found in an article entitled "Death Squads' Flack in El Salvador,
Clinton's Man in Kosovo," by Mark Ames and Matt Taibi, printed in the May
16-30 issue of CounterPunch. You can contact CounterPunch at 3220 N Street
NW, Suite 346, Washington, D.C. 20007 ($40/year), 1-800-840-3683,
www.counterpunch.org.
|