| |
The Invisible Hand: A Contemporary Fairy Tale
by Lansing Scott
Once upon a time there was a land where the people placed great faith in
an Invisible Hand. The Invisible Hand was a mythical creature of great
magical powers, which had first been described by a wise man long ago named
Adam Smith.
Smith explained that when people got together for the purpose of buying
and selling and making things, all they had to do was act in their own
self-interest and their actions would be guided "as if by an Invisible Hand"
to create the greatest good for everyone.
In other words, this amazing creature could magically transform greed
into public benefit. All that was needed was that everyone had to be
competing against everyone else all the time, and that this competition had
to take place with a minimum of rules and regulations. Cooperating or making
rules were Bad Things, and would only prevent the Invisible Hand from working
its magic.
People liked the fable of the Invisible Hand, because it told them they
could Do Good by being greedy. Of course, the greediest people liked this
story best, and so helped convince everyone that, with such amazing magical
powers, the Invisible Hand should be allowed to control everything that
involved buying, selling, or making things. And indeed, the Invisible Hand
rewarded these people richly.
Over the years, the Invisible Hand did bring great wealth to the land,
spreading enough of it around among enough people to keep them content. Even
though most of the wealth went to a small minority, the rest of the people
didn't seem to mind all that much. After all, if the Invisible Hand had given
enormous riches to some people, it must be a Good Thing.
Then one day the people who had reaped the greatest rewards from the
Invisible Hand all got together. From every country on Earth they came, for
the purpose of ensuring that everything that involved buying, selling, or
making things, anywhere on the planet, would be controlled by the Invisible
Hand, all the time. And that any rules that had been created that might
restrict the Invisible Hand would be eliminated.
Even though this meeting was very secretive, the rest of the people heard
about it.
"Hmmm," people thought. "Maybe before we agree to let the Invisible Hand
control everything in the world, we should think about this more carefully."
And so people started to make a list of the times the Invisible Hand had
brought Bad Things instead of Good Things.
This was a very long list, they soon discovered.
And so people said, "Maybe the Invisible Hand is good at doing some
things, but it seems to do other things very badly. Maybe we shouldn't let it
control everything after all. Perhaps it's time we started controlling things
with our own hands."
And so it was decided. And they lived happily ever after.
|