It Could Happen Here
by Maria Tomchick
It started on January 30, when water overflowed a containment dam at the
Baia Mare gold mine in Northwestern Romania. The water, contaminated with
cyanide and heavy metals, coursed through nearby streams and into the
Szamos and Tisa rivers, which flow into Hungary and Serbia, and eventually
into the Danube, the longest river in Europe.
Within a week, several tons of dead fish of all sizes and species washed
ashore along the banks of the Tisa. All aquatic life in the river--from
algae and the tiniest aquatic creatures up to fish that weighed as much as
a grown human--were killed. Some species of fish that live only in this
water system were completely wiped out--extinct within a matter of days.
Within two weeks, the spill covered a 30-mile stretch of the Tisa and the
Danube. Witnesses claimed that parts of the Danube were "all white with the
bellies of dead fish." Hunters began to find dozens of dead cattle, cats,
dogs, seagulls, deer, pheasants, ducks, and wildlife that rely on the Tisa
river for drinking water.
In a part of Europe that is largely rural and serves as a breadbasket for
the region, farms along the river banks cannot use water from the Tisa or
the Danube--or even their own nearby wells--to irrigate their crops.
Drinking water is being trucked in to towns that pump water from the
Danube.
Over 300 tons of dead fish have been pulled from the Tisa and the Danube
rivers in three countries. In the Yugoslavian section of the Danube alone,
over 400,000 birds rely on the fish in the river to help them survive the
winter. In another week or two, birds dead from starvation or from eating
poisoned fish may become as common as the heaping piles of dead fish
wrapped in nylon bags that litter the region. The problem of how to dispose
of the contaminated carcasses--now officially toxic waste--is only the
first step in a cleanup effort that could last for decades and cost well
over $100 million dollars.
And the problems will get worse as time passes. Currently, there are few
places to bury the fish carcasses, because seasonal heavy rains have turned
portions of the region into a swamp. Also, the bottoms of the slow-flowing
Tisa and Danube rivers are littered with piles of cold, dead fish that are
perfectly preserved, because the cyanide killed the bacteria that would
have decomposed them. Once the weather warms up, those fish will float to
the top and wash downstream onto the banks of towns and cities, creating a
second, larger mess.
The spill also carried high doses of heavy metals: iron, copper, mercury,
and lead. These contaminates won't become diluted over time, like the
cyanide will. They will persist as poisons in the river, the soil, the
groundwater, and the food chain for decades.
The Baia Mare spill has been called the worst environmental disaster in
Europe since Chernobyl.
It couldn't happen here in the U.S., right?
Wrong. A comparable cyanide spill has already occurred in the U.S.--at the
Summitville mine in southern Colorado in 1992. Cyanide water spilled into
the Alamosa River system, killing everything in the water within 17 miles
of the spill site. The Alamosa cleanup continues to this day, and the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency estimates that the final costs will be at
least $170 million. Said Steve D'Esposito of the Mineral Policy Center:
"You're having to re-establish an entire ecosystem ... So it takes years,
if not decades." D'Esposito also acknowledged that the Alamosa spill
contaminated groundwater and soil in the region; to this day, local farmers
have to test their crops every year for cyanide contamination.
Cyanide is used in gold-mining to increase the yield (and the profits) from
low-grade ores. Cyanide compounds are mixed with water and flushed through
ores to extract tiny flecks of gold; the process is so efficient that it
can extract nearly 100% of the gold from a pile of ore dust. But the
process produces a highly-toxic waste, which is usually stored in
containment ponds. Experience shows that, over time, containment ponds can
fail, and the results can be devastating.
The Baia Mare mine is operated jointly by the Romanian government and an
Australian company, Esmeralda Exploration Ltd., and both claim the affects
of the spill into the Tisa and Danube rivers have been exaggerated. Similar
claims about the effects of cyanide have been made by the Houston-based
company, Battle Mountain Gold Inc., which is still pursuing a
cyanide-leaching gold mine in Okanogan county in Eastern Washington.
The proposed Crown Jewel mine has survived a number of setbacks. Last
March, the federal government ruled against it on the basis of the 1872
mining law that limits the per-acre amount of rock that can be dumped in
the area surrounding a mine. Senator Slade Gorton, always ready to serve
big business, came to the rescue by inserting two paragraphs into an
unrelated bill on relief for victims of Hurricane Mitch; those two
paragraphs exempted the Crown Jewel mine from the 1872 law.
Hardworking opponents of the mine, including the Okanogan Highlands
Alliance (a citizens' watchdog group) and the Confederated Tribes of the
Colville Reservation, continued their fight by filing an appeal at the
state level. On January 19 of this year--less than two weeks before the
Baia Mare disaster in Europe--the Washington State Pollution Control
Hearings Board ruled against the Crown Jewel mine. In their ruling, the
pollution board said that Battle Mountain Gold Inc. had not adequately
provided for pollution control, and the mine would pull too much water from
the overused creeks in the area.
The struggle over the Crown Jewel mine, however, is not finished. On
February 10, the company met with Gov. Gary Locke (who supports the mine)
and the State Department of Ecology (which initially issued the permits for
the mine) to hammer out a strategy to save Crown Jewel. The mine may yet go
forward.
Battle Mountain wants to rip at least 97 million tons of rock from the
eastern face of a mountain located mostly on publicly owned U.S. Forest
Service land. They expect to employ about 140 people. But if cyanide spills
over into the local watershed and spreads down 30 miles of river,
destroying everything in its path, those jobs will mean nothing. Surely
eastern Washington farmers, a powerful lobby in Olympia, should be taking a
closer look at something that could so easily threaten their livelihoods.
And, of course, all the talk about saving the salmon in the Columbia River
watershed will be meaningless if a large portion of that river system is
completely and thoroughly destroyed.
|