Exploitation of Education
It's not easy to dodge the saturation of commercialization these days.
Everywhere we go, so does advertising: in the media, on transportation,
even
the address tags that are put on luggage. Advertisement in these places is
expected for the most part, but commercialization in our public schools? As
ludicrous as it may sound, such exploitation among our youth is a very real
matter within Seattle's public schools.
In October 1998, the Seattle School District exclusively signed a 5-year
vending machine contract with the Coca-Cola Corporation. The public was
outraged over this deal, emphasizing concerns over schools encouraging
children to consume an unhealthy product.
Since then, the Seattle School District has signed another contract with
N2H2, an Internet filtering service that prohibits kids from visit
"unsuitable" websites. This deal waives a $500 per month fee for the
service,
and allows an ad banner to be displayed on every web page that students
visit.
The reason why this commercial activity is permitted is simple: Seattle
Public Schools need the money. In 1996, the District faced a budget deficit
of $35 million, so the "Advertising and Corporate Sponsorship Policy,"
(which would allow for corporate advertising and sponsorship within Seattle
schools) was passed. The Seattle School Board passed the policy in hopes of
helping schools produce funds to reduce the District's deficit. After
months
of public outcry, the policy was rescinded. A subsequent "Committee on
Commercial Activity and Advertising in the Seattle Public Schools," with a
businesswoman as chair, met for eleven months and submitted recommendations
that were utterly ignored. Four years later, there is still no policy on
either allowing or banning commercialism in schools.
So what's wrong with a little endorsement in the school environment?
Everything. Not only are we encouraging our kids to be materialistic, we
are also teaching them to want things they don't need. Although the
District may not intentionally try to exploit our children, the whole
experience damages the overall quality of education, not to mention the
accountability of the educational system. And it gives the appearance that
the schools--government-funded institutions--are endorsing private
corporations and their products. If anything, schools should be the one
place
where our kids can escape commercialism.
To resolve this problem, a group known as The Citizens' Campaign for
Commercial-Free Schools (CCCS) has drafted a recommended policy, which will
be proposed to the Seattle School Board. The policy calls for Seattle
Public Schools to be "commercial-free zones." Not only would the District
and individual schools be prohibited from accepting paid and non-paid
advertising, logos would appear on items solely for the purpose of
identification.
CCCS can be contacted at www.scn.org/cccs; 206-726-4142; 3724 Burke Ave.
N., Seatle WA 98103; cccs@drizzle.com.
Debbie Shih
|