A Sickening Spectacle
by Geov Parrish
The Fat Tuesday Mardi Gras violence was, in a word, sickening. Far more
than, say, the Santee shootings (can't trust those white boys!), or the
Bush Presidency, The fact that feral gangs of young people exist isn't all
that exceptional, but Seattle's Fat Tuesday evoked the worst of modern
America for at least a couple of additional, chilling reasons.
First, we can put Kris Kime down as the first death directly attributable
to the Paul Schell Re-Election Campaign.
(Granted, there are a few intermediary steps involved. And it may not be
the first; after Paul's announcement, somebody jumping off a bridge may
have left behind a note we don't know about.)
Public officials, through action or inaction, contribute to the deaths of
citizens all the time. But rarely is the chain of causation so clear and so
avoidable. The most regrettable aspect of the next day's earthquake is that
it came only hours before the start of an uproar that would have guaranteed
the removal of this breathtakingly incompetent and venal man from elected
office once and for all.
Let's review. 1) Young thugs roam the streets, preying on the weak and
drunk. They attack a young woman. Why? Because they could. 2) Kris Kime
comes to her aid. Why? Because unlike most of the Mardi Gras revelers, he
was honorable enough not to stand by and watch someone getting the life
thrashed out of her. 3) The thugs turn on Kime. Why? See 1). 4) Riot cops
are present in great numbers, and, unlike Kime, are fully equipped with
riot gear and a full arsenal of weaponry--not to mention professional
training in intervention and a professional obligation to act. They stand
nearby and watch. Why? They are under standing orders to stay put. 5) Why?
Because the police department and the mayor were strongly (and rightly)
criticized for acting too soon when there were few problems the
previous weekend. This wouldn't matter--to the point where they stick to it
even as a citizen is obviously and publicly being murdered--unless the
order had come from very high up. Like from a man who was trying hard to
please the public and remain in office, and who could sleep comfortably
while hell was paid.
Schell shrugs it off as a police matter--the "not my department" routine.
In Seattle-Tacoma-Everett, 3.2 million people know this is bullshit, just
as it was when, during WTO, Paul used the same line to disavow police
abuses so flagrant and well-documented as to horrify the world. After the
events of the weekend, if Schell didn't at least review the plan, that's
incompetence, too.
If he didn't, Kerlikowske did, with an eye toward pleasing Schell. But
watching silently while the public commits violent crimes is not in
Kerlikowske's mold; he's a cop. Schell is not. Standing down no matter
what is a civilian's order, and the new police chief was following
orders. This has Schell's bloody fingerprints all over it.
After what happened to Norm Stamper, Kerlikowske must be wondering how he,
too, got sucked into taking one for the mayor--right down to explaining
that the situation was "too dangerous." That's what we pay police for, and
they take pride in it. If it's too dangerous an action for riot cops to
save an obviously threatened life, it's too dangerous for anyone to be
there, and the crowd must be dispersed.
Apologists cite the difficulty of pleasing everyone. You go in too early,
people criticize you. You go in too late, people criticize you.
Here's an easy guide: If nothing's happening, don't assault crowds with
riot cops, tear gas, pepper spray, and sting bombs. If someone's dying,
act. It's really not rocket science.
It wasn't Schell's fault, obviously, that those violent kids wanted to act
out on a mass scale. But it was his fault that they got the chance. Schell
has now proven, once again, that his judgment is far, far worse than poor;
wittingly or not, Schell is an extremely dangerous man in a crisis. We were
lucky Paul Schell didn't kill anybody during WTO. This time, our luck ran
out.
And the remarkable thing is, almost nobody (present company excepted) is
calling him on it. Usually, media and pundits are reluctant to point out
the occasions when government acts, and it hurts someone. This time,
government didn't act, and the result: one dead, 71 injured, an
unknown number of women raped.
Which brings us to the second disturbing aspect of Fat Tuesday. It wasn't
just the police that stood and watched. There were thousands of people
milling the streets in the midst of these crimes. When the attacks
occurred, they almost always stood and watched. One person couldn't do much
(and, as Kime's case showed, it was extremely dangerous), but a lot of
people could.
At the very least, you'd expect that they'd go running for the cops. Nope.
What does this say about Americans' willingness--even while drunk--to
sanguinely watch while horrors are committed in front on us?
A sickening, sickening spectacle.
Our local media also didn't exactly distinguish itself. Let's set aside the
dropping (for a time) of Fat Tuesday for breathless earthquake coverage,
when Mardi Gras was a much bigger story in terms of what we need to do in
the future to address it. That was predictable. But there were other
disturbing aspects of the media coverage.
There were at least four full television crews--and who knows how many
others--reporting up close from scenes where people were being brutally
attacked. I'm sure that if any of them actually tried to intervene in the
crimes being perpetrated, we would have heard about it.
And then there was the coverage itself. In the first day, every single
image of violence that was broadcast was black-on-white attacks. Witnesses
conflict as to whether this was the only combination of violence happening,
and whether it was racially motivated--but our chickenshit local media
didn't even acknowledge that this might be an issue until three days
later, when African-American leaders met with Schell and Kerlikowske. And
if those images weren't representative, a whole different, ominous set of
questions comes up.
Even more invisible, in terms of media commentary after the fact, was the
violence against women. It was well-established that women were attacked,
and at least some eyewitnesses were claiming to have witnessed rapes, but
that didn't make it into the news until SPD acknowledged it ten days
later.
All in all, it's hard to perceive of anyone who came out of this ugly mess
looking good. Probably the only thing it helped was the mayoral ambitions
of Mark Sidran. As Bruce Anderson, the sagacious editor of the Anderson
Valley Advertiser, is fond of saying, these are, indeed, the Last Days.
|