| |
Why Pay Taxes?
by Geov Parrish
As with so many other instances--corporate welfare, bureaucratic contempt,
Pentagon bottom-feeding, and state brutality, among many others--the
sweeping
and contemptuous attempt by the Bush Administration to shift the bulk of
this
country's tax burden on to middle and working classes raise an obvious but
seldom-asked question: why do so many people pay their income taxes?
This is not a rhetorical question. At the local, state, and especially
federal level, in our political system low, middle, and even upper middle
income people get far less back in services and benefits from the federal
government than they pay in; and the extremely wealthy--the top 1%--get far
more. Military spending, non-military corporate welfare, and interest on
the
national debt alone account for something like 60% of the federal budget
each year, and it's growing. The impact is even greater when considering
how
much money isn't in the budget in the first place because of what the rich
don't pay--which is about to get far worse. Corporations and
high-income folks get more tax breaks each year, while already-inadequate
social spending continues to be gutted and more and more prisons get built
to
hold the people who can't cope.
The very rich are getting richer while most everyone else's wages are
stagnant or dropping. Governments--funded largely by the wealthy--are one
of
the primary mechanisms for this wealth transfer. The money that keeps the
Dow
Jones over 10 bazillion--just wait til that bubble is really burst--
isn't being newly printed; that would be inflationary. But it's coming from
somewhere--from your pockets, into the pockets of Bill Gates, Boeing, Paul
Allen, and Co., and much of it via Tax Day. A relatively tiny portion of
the
proceeds then gets recycled into purchasing politicians and policies that
will ensure a tax, legal, and regulatory structure (i.e., "relief") ever
more
favorable to them and less favorable to everyone else. The ordinary citizen
today has little meaningful choice or input into almost any important
public
policy issue at the state level, and none nationally.
So why do so many people pay their taxes?
Two hundred and twenty or so years ago this was called "taxation without
representation" and we were so angry we threw out the government. Today,
the
word "revolution" is trademarked by Nike; we masses vent our frustration by
laughing along with the Tax Day jokes on late-night TV, or going further
into
debt at the Tax Day sales at the mall.
But what if we refused? The federal government in particular is vulnerable;
its income tax system is based on voluntary compliance, and the IRS--though
fearsome in its media-assisted reputation--is essentially a very large, and
not even very efficient, collection agency. People laugh off collection
agency bills simply because they don't want to (or can't) pay, but quake in
terror of the IRS when the money isn't just going to a private business--
it's going, in large quantities, to an institution now dedicated at the
highest levels to enriching its patrons even if it means killing you. We
are volunteering to buy the bullets for our firing squads.
Why does virtually everybody volunteer?
This isn't a Freemen or Posse Comitatus-type question of the legitimacy of
taxation. Quite the opposite; our current tax system is ethically bankrupt
specifically because portions of everyone's labor should contribute
to
the collective well-being of the community (rather than, say, Paul Allen's
net worth). The issues here are where the money goes, how it's being spent,
and how the spending decisions are made. People struggling to pay the rent,
who can't afford health care, have no job security or retirement prospects,
can't find affordable daycare, college, or anything in between for their
kids, and so on, are tithing 30% or more of their income to people who
already have enough yachts and private luxury jets to get by.
There are a few folks saying no. War tax resisters refusing, for reasons of
conscientious objection, to fund militarism (by, for example, inflating
deductions so no money is withheld from a paycheck--one of many
strategies);
people intentionally living under the taxable income; people who, forced to
choose between enough food to feed the family in April or paying the IRS
bill, make the eminently political decision to forego hunger. As usual,
there
will be small groups of folks leafleting at area post offices, and having a
vigil or protest downtown, on Tax Day. (See the calendar.) You'd think
there'd be millions.
Resisting taxes--symbolically or fully--has risks. It can be a nuisance, or
it can complicate one's life immensely, and no one should undertake it
without understanding those risks. But there's also risks involved in
passively cooperating with our own demise. And it's simply amazing that
more people don't look closely at which risk is greater.
Nonviolent Action Community of Cascadia--a community group that has
supported ETS! since its inception--administers the largest escrow account
of
resisted tax money in the US, by holding the money for resisters (it's
retrievable, so people aren't left in the lurch by an IRS seizure),
reinvesting it in socially responsible programs of the sort the state
doesn't
fund adequately, and using the interest for peace, social justice, and
resistance organizing. (About $7,000 will be granted to other groups this
year.) NACC also has resources and experienced war tax resistance (WTR)
counselors available for folks who need more information or counseling.
This year's grant applications, available to groups who engage in radical
political organizing not normally funded by granting institutions, are due
on April 16. For information on the escrow account, counseling, or the
grant
applications, call 206-547-0952.
|