2001 Media Follies
by Maria Tomchick & Geov Parrish
This is the sixth year that ETS! has looked at the most over-hyped and
under-reported stories of the year. We started doing the list in 1996 with
the perception that the US public, instead of getting the information it
needed to make informed decisions in a democracy, was being distracted with
an endless barrage of feel-good trivia.
And every year, it's gotten worse. But 2001, and in particular the past
three months, have reached a new low in terms of actively misleading the
public. This sort of list has become more important than ever.
For the same reasons, alternative media is more important than ever. But
it's no substitute for demanding that America's big networks and newspapers
stop acting as a combination of stenographers to power and shills for their
entertainment divisions, advertisers, and corporate owners. Without that
pressure, we'll get the garbage we deserve, and the intellectual junk food
that many people demand. But while they clamor for Harry Potter, Lord of
the Rings, Super Bowl coverage, Survivor XIV, and ten-day Accu-Pinpoint
Astrological Weather, here's the news they did, and didn't, get:
Most Overrated Stories of the Year
The Mariners. Summer is a good time to go on a long vacation away
from Seattle; otherwise you have to eat, drink, and breathe Ichiro.
Psychologizing about how much our nation has changed after September
11. The daily newspapers and TV news shows need to remind us that
"we've all changed" almost every day. After all, we might forget. Uh ...
what was I talking about? And hey, how 'bout a story or two on how the rest
of the world hasn't changed, nor the US' role in it? Bonus demerits
to NPR and other outlets that have been trotting out daily maudlin WTC
victims' stories for three months solid, a blatant propaganda effort to
remind people that we need revenge for, um, we forget.
Federal interest rate cuts. Much hoopla precedes federal interest
rate cuts, because supposedly it makes it cheaper for businesses and
consumers to borrow money. But credit card interest rates haven't gone
down, and mortgage rates have dropped only a tiny bit. Stock prices are
continuing to swoon, companies are laying off more people, stores are
begging for customers, and we've reached the conclusion that monetary
policy is a load of horseshit.
Whatever the stock market is doing. Before the collapse, lots of
folks used to check stock and mutual fund prices daily, if not hourly. Now
nobody cares. We love it. But Wall Street can't stand not being the center
of attention, and it shows. Quit whining!
Boeing moves its headquarters. Local politicians, newspapers, and
Boeing employees thought it was the end of the world when the corporate
sharks swam to Chicago ... we say "good riddance! And extend our sympathies
to our friends and ripped-off taxpayers in Chicago!"
Bill and Melinda Gates' charitable donations. Look. They have
to give away money every year to get a break on their taxes, okay? Their
donations are big because they've got so much money. So give it a rest.
The end of the recession is near! In truth, it's really getting
further away every day. But some people just can't see that the bubble has
burst until the soap's all puddled at their feet.
And last, but not least, the fucking Harry Potter movie. The books
are a lot of fun. Kids love them. More kids are reading now than ever
before, especially boys. Yes, we know. But the Harry Potter marketing
phenomenon has got to go. We here at Eat the State! read a lot of books,
including children's literature. Harry Potter books rank second to a number
of children's classics, including nearly all of Roald Dahl's books. There
is no Charlie & the Chocolate Factory action figure or happy meal. And
that's the way it should be.
The Year's Most Important Underreported Stories
First we'll list the local stories, then work outward to the national and
international stories.
The 2001 elections might never have happened, if you were reading
the newspapers. Who did you vote for? Most people didn't. And damn few of
us remember who was elected and who lost.
In the wake of Tim Eyman's successful initiative to limit increases in
property taxes (remember?), Washington State is headed for a budget crisis.
So Governor Locke and "legislative leaders" appointed 11 people to a new
taskforce to study Washington's tax structure. Who's on the panel? The
usual big business types (Bill Gates, Sr. is the chairman). What they come
up with will certainly not raise taxes for businesses.
Meanwhile, some smart folks have pointed out that Washington State's
budget shortfall could be eliminated if the legislature repealed special
tax credits for businesses, including Boeing's exemption from sales tax
on airplanes. You won't see this in the Seattle Times.
Nor has there been much reporting on the fact that instead, the vast
majority of state budget cuts will be in programs and services to the
state's neediest citizens. Not that our legions of newly needy will
need the state's help or anything. And past safety net cuts--made in times
of prosperity--are kicking in, too; a large number of folks on Welfare
to Work are just beginning to reach the end of their benefits, with no jobs
in sight.
A new Alaskan way viaduct is in the planning stages, with no debate
in the local papers. Ditto for expanding the 520 bridge.
The Bonneville Power Authority killed the best salmon run in recent
history. During the drought this summer, the BPA refused to spill
enough water over dams on the Columbia River to flush young fingerlings out
to sea. 80-90% of the fish population died in the river, which will effect
runs well into the future.
Microsoft and the Bush Administration gutted anti-trust laws.
Meanwhile, the local press quoted Microsoft's lawyers ad nauseam, reported
the price of Microsoft stock, and whined about how badly rich peoples'
stock options are suffering.
The Seattle Police Department needs a civilian review board. Mardi
gras, the suspicious shootings of Aaron Roberts and David John Walker,
complaints from the African American community, and this year's WTO debacle
are the direct result of the lack of civilian oversight. In addition, the
highly flawed inquest process was given ample exposure in ETS!, but nowhere
else.
California energy prices sank the movement for energy privatization.
Several states put on hold or canceled their plans to privatize utilities
after California's mess showed them what privatization really means: the
taxpayer takes it in the shorts.
Massive protests greeted George Bush's Jan. 20 inauguration.
Protesters were an overwhelming presence at key points on the Pennsylvania
Avenue inaugural parade route, and TV cameras carefully avoided those
areas, the fences surrounding the parade route, or any acknowledgment of
public anger over last December's coup d'etat.
Bush and the Republicans have shamelessly used the September 11 tragedy
to try to push through reactionary legislation. The list is long:
Fast-track trade authority, huge tax breaks and refunds for corporations, a
massive bailout for airline companies, a taxpayer funded safety net for the
insurance industry, a defense budget that's increasing far beyond what the
military asked for, a revival of the missile defense boondoggle, and $3
billion spent so far to catch one guy. The only thing they haven't got yet
is permission to drill for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. Give
them a week or two. Meanwhile, urgent social needs, like prescription
drug benefits and other health care crises, have been swept off the
table.
John Ashcroft and George Bush have suspended large portions of the Bill
of Rights for those "suspected" of being terrorists, and anyone else in
the general vicinity. They've accomplished it by doing an end-run around
Congress and issuing executive orders, leading House Republicans
(members of their own party, no less) to call the Bush administration a
tyranny.
Last week, Ashcroft made a special trip to Europe to try and soothe our
allies in Britain, Spain, Belgium, Germany, and Italy (Ashcroft, it seems,
is terrified of France). Notably, the French government is offering to help
defend Zacarias Moussaoui, the only person in the US to be charged
with complicity in the 9/11 attacks. Spain is refusing to extradite
terrorist suspects because of Bush's military tribunals. The world is
clearly appalled, but the US press is asleep at the wheel. When the land of
Franco and the Spanish inquisition has to lecture the US on due process,
you'd think there's a story afoot.
Only the Wall Street Journal has reliably and repeatedly reported that
the anthrax spores found in three letters to congressmen is a US
weapons-grade variety. Yes, that means either a military or ex-military
guy sold it to the perpetrator, or the perp is another Timothy McVeigh.
The Bush tax cut was a flop long before 9/11. The piddly refunds
people received were quickly spent on paying off debt or buying essentials,
not on shopping sprees, as the Republicans had hoped. Which means more tax
cuts will also fail to help the economy. But that hasn't stopped the
Bushies from pushing for them.
And almost nobody knows--because the media didn't tell them--that the
rebates weren't rebates at all That $300 will simply be added to your
tax bill next year instead. The government is getting every penny from you
it originally expected to, unless you're in the upper income tax brackets
whose tax rates were permanently cut. The "Bush rebate" was a cheap
accounting trick, and a massive fraud perpetrated on those who thought they
were getting extra money, a fraud obediently reinforced by most news
reports.
The murder of one anti-globalization protester and the beating,
detention, and torture of hundreds more by police in Genoa, Italy, and
its political aftermath, shocked the European press, but not the US press.
There were three advances in the struggle for cheap medicines for the
Third World this year. First, a South African court case against major
pharmaceutical companies forced drug companies to lower their prices on
AIDS medicines to Africa. Second, more countries are now lining up to pass
laws giving them the right to buy generic versions of patented drugs. And,
finally, the WTO was forced to retreat and allow countries the right to buy
generics when necessary, without the threat of being sued through the WTO.
The Afghan interim president, Hamid Karzai, is a CIA man. This
obvious fact is left out of the US media's biographies of Karzai, but the
foreign press is quick to point out that he worked for the CIA during the
Soviet invasion of Afghanistan and is working for them now, stirring up the
southern Pashtun tribes against the Taliban. And he'll work for them in the
future, too.
The Northern Alliance's most visible warlord, General Dostum, is a
former Soviet and Taliban general renowned for his brutality. That
brutality was on full display after Dostum's forces took Mazar-i-Sharif, to
the yawning indifference of US, but not global, media.
Afghanistan's women can't vote. The US press goes on about the two
women cabinet members in the interim government, but Afghan women don't
even have the vote yet, much less any identification papers that would
allow them to register to vote, even if it were legal. And there are no
protections for women who want to cast off the burqa (the Northern Alliance
is as socially conservative as the Taliban). A democracy can't exist with
over half its population disenfranchised.
The war is about oil, but not about an oil pipeline through
Afghanistan, as some folks claim. No, it's about "stabilizing the region"
to prevent radical Islamic Afghanistan from exporting nationalist Islamic
guerrillas north to the Caspian Sea dictatorships that the US supports.
(Gotta keep those dictators gainfully employed extracting oil for our
SUVs.)
And finally, the US remains the biggest terrorist nation in the
world. We're the largest arms exporter. We give weapons to Israel
(which is assassinating members of the Palestinian government, for god's
sake). We supply Indonesia (which just murdered a major opposition leader
in Irian Jaya a couple weeks ago). We support a Mexican government that's
busy torturing peasants even as you read this. Dictatorships in Latin
America, the Middle East, and Asia would fall like dominoes without US
taxpayer money and the help of US corporations. Behind it all lies the
implied threat: the US military will crush any regime that strays too far
out of line. No combination of world powers has been able or willing to
hold this rogue state accountable for its transgressions. That's why the
world loves us.
|