Planting Democracy
by Troy Skeels
The words caught my eye as I walked through Oaxaca's town square: Zapata
Vive, Su Lucha Sigue (Zapata Lives, his struggle continues). This and
other slogans were painted on the several-hundred-years-old walls of
Oaxaca's state government palace.
This wasn't hit and run graffiti done in the middle of the night. The
authors were nearby, around a hundred of them, along with hand painted
banners and a sound system. A gas fired cook stove was pushed up against
one of the building's supporting pillars. A makeshift latrine, a bucket
enclosed in a screen of sheets stood a little ways off. One man softly
played ballads on a guitar while small groups chatted and others rested on
flattened cardboard boxes along the wall. In contrast to any similar
situation in the Land of the Free, there wasn't a police officer in sight.
Just another planton in Oaxaca's Zocalo.
This demonstration sparked my immediate interest not only for the
relatively rare direct references to Zapatismo such as never
again a Mexico without us but also because the government had just
spent considerable effort cleaning the vestiges of previous demonstrations
from the palace walls. In fact, they weren't quite done. Twenty yards away
three men were diligently chipping away at some stubborn paste left behind
from a previous poster. Like painting the Golden Gate Bridge, it seems that
cleaning the walls of Oaxaca's Government Palace is never finished, merely
completed in time to start again.
The accompanying banners indicated that the campesinos belonged to CODECI,
the initials for the Committee for the Defense of the Citizens. Most
interesting of all, the banners encompassed issues important to several of
Oaxaca's 16 indigenous ethnic groups. In a place where people from
neighboring villages often have trouble cooperating to address common
problems, the sight of banners expressing the concerns of diverse groups
throughout the state was an intriguing sign of unity.
After I found a group spokesman my first question was, "What is the reason
for this demonstration?" I knew this was going to be an enjoyable if not
altogether informative encounter when he answered, "Because the government
is a bastard and we are fed up."
Eventually I managed to determine they were indigenous Cuicatecos from San
Andres Teotilalapan, a town with an adult population of about 500 people in
the Sierra Madre del Norte. This mountain town is high enough up that, even
in tropical Oaxaca, February can be just as cold as it is in Seattle.
Among the graffiti and banners were the common demands for the ouster of
their local legislator. "What is the problem with your legislator?" I
asked. "Well, for one thing," replied the spokesman, "he won the election
through fraud. Like George Bush in the United States when everybody knows
that in reality Gore was the winner. Right?"
They might live in a remote community but they are apparently well
informed.
Unlike a multitude of other demonstrations denouncing electoral fraud, in
this case both the winning and losing candidate belong to same party, the
PRI. In many parts of Oaxaca the PRI is still the only party that exists.
And, as I am learning, some PRI politicians are considered to be honest and
sincerely seeking reform. (Just as I am learning that many politicians from
the progressive PRD are considered to be hopelessly corrupt).
Typically the protesters were accusing the local PRI machine of
manipulating the vote to fraudulently elect the legislator. This
politician, they say, is the patron of five cacique families who, through
wealth, derived political influence; and, through simple thuggery, steal
community lands and resources.
As it turned out, the state governor wasn't in town that day to hear their
complaints. He was in Mexico City conducting his own planton
demanding the federal government come through with promised funds to build
a superhighway across the Isthmus of Tehuantepec. But the governor's rather
symbolic planton lasted only 12 hours. These somewhat more hardy campesino
will maintain their encampment several days while their chosen
representatives and those of CODECI are inside the building meeting with
the governor's staff.
The roots of CODECI began in the 1950s when two large dams were built in
the Papaloapan river basin. In the words of CODECI's founders, "These
projects, far from bringing benefits to our region, dislodged thousands of
indigenous families from their lands, initiated the erasure of our race,
and corrupted the traditional values and cultures of these indigenous
towns." The flooding of vast areas to create the reservoirs began decades
of conflict among and between the Chinantecos and Mazatecos in the region
as farmers struggled for control over the remaining lands.
In 1996 a group of indigenous Chinantecos influenced by the Zapatista
uprising of the EZLN got together to address these problems in a new way.
CODECI was created as a self-defense organization through the efforts of
several communities working in common. The founders reasoned that together
"it was possible to put pressure on the government authorities in a more
organized way." They were done struggling among themselves over diminishing
resources and likewise finished with waiting quietly for government
promises that never came.
Setting to work, CODECI pressured the state government to intervene to
retrieve community lands that had been taken over by caciques, a task that
no individual group of campesinos could have accomplished.
As CODECI successes continued (they claim over 1,000 hectares retrieved
from caciques to date), the organization attracted more interested
communities. As the organization strengthened, they began undertaking
public works and environmental projects of their own design or that had
gotten stalled in the government bureaucracy. Additionally they have
created their own human rights committees and have allied with other
similar campesino organizations in nearby regions. Among their current
concerns is pressuring the federal government to reimburse the Chinanteco
and Mazateco communities whose lands were affected by the construction of
the Papaloapan river dams.
Today in Oaxaca's Zocalo it's too early to tell what will come of the
current planton. Meanwhile CODECI is planning a march on Mexico City in
April to press the federal government for restitution for the lands
affected by the dams. Additionally they have declared their solidarity with
the campesinos of Texcoco and Atenco (outside Mexico City) fighting against
the proposed airport slated for their farmlands. They are pressing for the
federal congress to pass a true indigenous rights law, and have demanded
that the government locate and prosecute those responsible for the murder
of human rights lawyer Digna Ochoa.
CODECI, like its sister organizations throughout Mexico, represents a
change perhaps deeper and more profound than the mere changing of political
parties resulting from the most recent presidential elections. This is real
people planting real democracy with their own hands and on their own lands.
|