What's in the Energy Bill? Stealth Nuclear Power Plants
by Mina Hamilton
Under the guise of protecting the American public from more blackouts, the
Republican leadership is promoting a disastrous Energy Bill that promotes
nuclear power.
Thought we'd beat back the idea of nukes? Think again. With no fanfare and
certainly no media reports, last year the US Congress handed big energy
giants like Exelon, Entergy, and Dominion $1 million a piece to go out and
evaluate sites in Ohio, Virginia, and Mississippi for new reactors.
Now as a Senate and House conference committee tackles the Energy Bill the
push to revive this almost dead industry is in high gear. There are two
bills, one from the House and one from the Senate, that will be the subject
of negotiation in the conference committee. Each bill endorses the concept
of something called the 2010 program. This antediluvian program would build
50 new nukes by the year 2020.
Let it sink in: Fifty nukes! That's about a 50% increase of the number of
nukes currently on line in the US (103 nukes).
To add insult to injury, the program to build a whole new generation of
nukes would depend on the US taxpayer to finance huge amounts of the
staggering costs.
As we go to press the exact provisions are unclear. Yet Republican pro-nuke
enthusiasts and, in particular, Senator Pete Domenici of New Mexico are
talking of inserting wording that would support massive subsidies with
possibly up to 50% of construction costs of new nuclear power plants to be
paid for by taxpayers. Also under discussion are substantial taxpayer
subsidies for decommissioning costs.
An earlier bill promoted by Senator Domenici advocated $271 million dollars
for construction of new nuclear power plants, research and development on
"advanced" reactor designs, development of "fast track" licensing
procedures (these might ban legal interventions by citizens) and other
goodies for the dead-in-the-water nuclear industry. In addition, his bill
gave the nod to taxpayers splitting the costs with industry.
It's hard to believe that these guys are serious.
Somehow the fact that taxpayers are already reeling from a lousy economy,
plus the burden of tax benefits to the super-wealthy, plus the sky-high tab
of the Iraq War (which is about to zoom upwards by $87 billion), has
escaped their notice.
Somehow they also missed the disastrous history of nuclear power over the
last 25 years.
No matter that the last nuke to come on line in the US, the Tennessee Watts
Bar nuclear power plant, cost $8 billion and took 23 years to build.
No matter that in 1986 the burning reactors at Chernobyl in Russia forced
the evacuation of 100,000 people within a 30-kilometer radius, permanently
contaminated significant areas in the Ukraine and Belarus, and spewed
radioactive poisons as far as Sweden, Norway, and the US.
No matter that the Three Mile Island nuclear power plant accident came
within a hair's breadth of suffering a meltdown and making huge sections of
Pennsylvania uninhabitable.
No matter that nobody knows what to do with the approximately 45,000 tons
of long-lived nuclear waste that is currently sitting in irradiated fuel
pools at nuclear reactors.
No matter that safe, benign sources of energy derived from energy
efficiency programs, conservation, wind and solar power, and fuel-efficient
automobiles would all cost billions less, could be implemented on a much
faster schedule, would generate many more jobs and make Americans less
dependent upon foreign oil.
No, the Republican leadership, taking advantage of Americans' sense of
vulnerability after the blackout of August 14, is ready to hand the nuclear
utilities a giant windfall.
What's being promoted in Washington is so out-of-touch with reality, so
1950s regressive, so dim-witted it's hard to grasp.
This foolish and dangerous nuclear revival is being promoted in 2003
despite the devastating attack on the World Trade Center, despite the clear
warning from Osama bin Laden's training camps in Afghanistan that nukes
might be targets (remember how US forces found crude maps of nuclear power
plants?), despite the total failure of Homeland Security, the Nuclear
Regulatory Commission, the utilities, or anybody else to take concrete
steps to protect Americans from the potentially disastrous threat posed by
terrorists to existing nuclear power plants.
We still have the shred of a democracy in the US. There is something
outraged citizens can do.
If you feel strongly about this matter, go to www.publiccitizen.org. In
thirty seconds you can send a fax to your Senator opposing the Energy Bill
with its provision for constructing new nuclear power plants. In addition,
at this crucial time while the Republican Conference Committee is
deliberating, letters and faxes to possible swing votes on the committee
are needed. These would include Senator Ben Nighthorse Campbell of
Colorado, Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, and Senator Bob Graham of Florida.
Graham is particularly key since he is a Presidential candidate. For
additional information go to www.nirs.org.
--Mina Hamilton was for many years co-director and then director of the
Radioactive Waste Campaign, a program to educate the public on the hazards
of nuclear power.
|