Volume 12, #11 February 7, 2008 POLITICS WITH BITE! CONTACT HELP previous BACK ISSUES next
A FORUM FOR ANTI-AUTHORITARIAN POLITICAL OPINION, RESEARCH AND HUMOR

Academic Bullies and the WASL

by Paul Rathgeb

Time for four square, dodge ball, basketball, freeze tag, jump rope, hop scotch, climbing the jungle gym, digging in the sand box, or just romping around with friends is getting the short end of the stick when it comes to school recess. There has been a significant rush among schools for more academics that is sweeping the nation. As reported in a Jan. 16 Seattle Times article ("Recess: time well spent, or time for a change?"), 40 percent of elementary schools according to the national Parent Teacher Association (PTA) either have chosen to scratch recess off the curriculum list or are considering doing away with it. Representative John McCoy (D-Tulalip.) is reintroducing Bill 1188 which would require most K-12 schools to provide at least an hour of unstructured play. Public school programs that run less than three hours per day fall under a half hour requirement.

The counter measure Bill backed and supported by the PTA is Senate Bill 6042, which requires schools to allot time for recess on the same scale as any other period during the school day. I suppose this depends on how long the actual subject periods last. For example, will a 35-minute period of recess be adequate for a squirmy six or seven year old for a whole day of school?

Much of the pressure for eradicating or chiseling away at recess time has been a shift towards additional academics. And much of the threat is a result of demand for schools to be assessed in accordance with how well their pupils perform on standardized tests. Schools in Washington deal with the Washington Assessment of Student Learning (WASL), a whopper of a test that began under-serving millions of kids since at least 1993, but not without discomforting side effects. For high schools the dropout rate has been on the rise, leaving many to not graduate as an outcome of low test scores on the WASL. Wikipedia cites that "only 34 percent in 2003 and 39 percent (about 48,000 students) in 2004 passed all sections of the WASL." The immensity of attention on the WASL has caused schools, students, teachers, and parents to lose sight of what quality education means. Mounting pressure to prep for the WASL has schools scrambling to reduce recess, sometime from two recesses to one, or from three to two.

School administrations and teachers continually face mounting pressure as they deal with state-mandated protocols to increase test scores that unfortunately equate to the sort of funding they will receive. The higher the standardized test scores, the more resources and materials the school in return receives. As a result, poorly funded schools fall into the ghettoized track, never able to propel forward because of low testing scores and the lack of supportive resources to break the mold. Schools that do not make the cut or the quota become delinquents, just bottom-feeders in the food chain. As a result, academics relating to standardized testing become the core of the curriculum, and real-life practical skills and recess go out the window.

Mandatory legislative assessment-based testing along with a continual onslaught for pushing academics at an unprecedented rate derails students from staying on track with their education, instead leaving many further behind.

How do test pushers expect students to perform if subjected to taking long hourly tests when they can't get their wiggles or restless behavior out on the play yard or in the gymnasium? Obviously time for recess is developmentally appropriate for gaining exercise, but there must be more to the value of having this time.

Recess--or any uninterrupted, unstructured playtime free of adult expectations--is a time for kids to engage with one another without the constructs of the classroom. This is a time during school that should be comforting for adults and the kids--a casual time to mingle within the school community. And this is a period where the ideal of socialization can occur without interruptions, without expectancies to perform academic duties, and where kids can invent their own lessons and games on the playground. When students are enrolled in schools that lean toward more formal instruction--which may be heavy with bureaucracy and other merit systems--recess time can be sanctity for kids.

But what can we do to regain their right to have adequate time for recess? Students, teachers and parents can be active in combating the WASL either through signing a document to opt out (which can be found online at http://nowasl.tripod.com/id3.html), which certainly won't get anyone on the teacher's favorite pupil list. Part of the mission of Students Against the WASL is: "To ensure the adequate, thorough education of all children, no matter sex, race, creed, or monetary status, nationwide. To review schools and provide an information network for parents, students, the community, and others, and to provide suggestions for schools in order that they might improve their standing."

Another informative site is Mothers Against WASL (mothersagainstwasl.org). In big bold letters a few lines down on the site it reads: The Test STOPS Here! And to take further action at the Mothers Against WASL site you can send an easy-to-fill-out form to the governor and customize a letter to your local legislature.

Both the Bills 1188 and 6042 share some common goals, but seem shrouded in rhetoric, leaving them quite ambiguous to the public. But this is for the educated reader to decide. And then there is always the question: Should government be meddling in the affairs of what time children have for unstructured play, or should this important decision be based on a municipal level, within the community or ultimately, to better serve each child? Again, this is for parents, students, teachers, and schools to decide.

Decentralizing the academic craze around testing is one method to ease the constraint or exploitation of recess. Besides, recess is not just a regular event to fill in the classroom schedule, it has as much precedence as Reading, Mathematics, Science, and Writing and it deserves to be cherished and protected, for years of life-long learning.

Paul Rathgeb is a progressive educator and frequently posts his writings at http://preschoolpunks.wordpress.com/.



subscribe / donate / tiny print / guidelines for writers / help / index

© 2008 Eat the State! All rights reserved.